Carcassonne - no not that one…

June 26th, 2005

We returned yesterday from a week’s holiday to Carcassonne in a gîte with another couple and their baby. We had a good time, although the first couple of days were around 38°C (100°F), so Ness, who is 32 weeks pregnant, found it tough. We had a lot of plans to see sights and get things done, but the holiday improved massively once we abandoned them and enjoyed just going to the local outdoor pool and eating in restaurants.

Carcassonne is a reasonable place to stay, but if you are on an itinerary it is only worth a day. The walled city looks great from the river, but is disappointing inside, mainly due to too many people and shops selling touristy tat.

Monty’s Gamble turned into Iain’s Gamble – a bit of a gaming disaster. My friend Julian had the stamina to read the rules but was much more interested in long evening meals and drinking red wine than working out how to play the game. I did not think he was being unreasonable, especially considering the heat of the evenings and the learning curve of the game. The fact that most of his father’s family were murdered by the Nazis in Vienna was certainly a factor in his lack of enthusiasm. He did say WWII was not his favourite genre, but I did not realise the level of his revulsion. :(

After much rules consulting, we played through the first day of the operation and then gave up. On the positive side, I learned a lot about wargaming and the history of the campaign. I would love to play more wargames, but I will have to be cleverer about picking opponents. In the mean time, does anyone want a Cyberboard game of Monty’s Gamble?

Julian did say he would play an ancients wargame with me. Do I wait for Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage to be reprinted or are there any others I should consider? A strategic level one is required, as he already plays a lot of DBA.

After I bowed to the inevitable, we played a couple of simple two-handed card games that were conversely surprisingly successful.

Dracula

Over six hands, players take turns to lay cards onto a 3×3 grid. One player scores the highest scoring row; the other scores the highest scoring column. Your score is multiplied if you get combinations of suits in your rows/columns.

There is plenty to think about tactically. It strongly reminds me of the Piecepack game, Power Lines. I’d say this is my second favourite traditional two-player card game, after Schnapsen.

Abstrac

24 cards are laid out in a row. Players take it in turns to draw one, two or three cards, trying to create sets or sequences. Your final score from cards drawn is multiplied by the number of cards your opponents takes. We played this too late at night to analyse it properly, but it is certainly interesting (in this case that means good).

As usual, David’s Parlett’s card games were top-drawer. Julian was very impressed.

4 Responses to “Carcassonne - no not that one…”

  1. alfredhw Says:

    Hm. Strategic-level ancients games…

    Well, Hellas should be coming out (he says) at some point from Columbia. For a somewhat more “wargamelike” experience, I might give Sword of Rome a look. Hannibal: Rome vs Carthage is great, but waiting for a reprint may prove impractical…I’m not sure there’s a reprint in any stage other than the “Wouldn’t it be Nice” stage.

  2. Iain Says:

    I know there’s not too much in the Ancient’s category. Hellas and Sword of Rome look good, but Sword of Rome might be a little too long…

    I just realised that strategic level medieval games should be considered too. Hammer of the Scots might be a good option, as I think I could get my brother-in-law to play too.

  3. Peter Haslehurst Says:

    Hammer of the Scots is a wonderful game, and has a significantly shorter and cleaner rulebook than most other wargames. Sword of Rome is a little more fiddly, and is designed for 4 players. Of course there is the whole Great Battles of History franchise, but these are tactical games and very fiddly. Sort of ASL for ancients.

  4. Iain Says:

    Thanks Peter. I have had my eye on HoS for ages. It does seem the logical choice.

Leave a Reply

OpenID

Anonymous